The Deception of Dark Patterns
Read time: 3.5 minutes || Read on web browser
Welcome to Mind Over Money, a weekly newsletter where I share actionable ideas to help you transform your relationship with money to build financial confidence and independence.
Today's topic: Dark Patterns
Do you have Amazon Prime? If so, have you tried to cancel it before?
In 2023, Amazon faced an FTC (Federal Trade Commission) lawsuit for what regulators called the "Iliad" of cancellation flows. Here’s how it worked: signing up for a Prime free trial took just one click, but canceling required navigating multiple hidden menus, confusing prompts, and endless "Are you sure?" pages. By the time users found the exit, another charge had already hit.
As you probably guessed, the way Amazon made you jump through hoops is intentional, not sloppy design. And there's a word to describe this kind of practice: Dark Patterns.
Dark patterns are manipulative interfaces where user experiences are carefully crafted to trick you into buying products, sharing personal data, or staying subscribed longer than you planned.
Unlike accidental design flaws, dark patterns are engineered with a deep understanding of human psychology, exploiting the cognitive biases and decision-making shortcuts we all rely on.
Here is an example of a simple newsletter signup with two elements of dark patterns: Visual Interference and Confirmshaming.
Visual Interference is where the business do its best to hide the information or action that it doesn’t want you to take. It is also at play when opt-out options are in smaller fonts, privacy policy links are in low contrast, or when vital information is otherwise obscured.
Confirmshaming guilt-trips you into compliance with shaming labels like "No, I like paying more than I need to". By targeting users' emotions and self-image, confirmshaming aims to increase the likelihood that users will give in to the desired action, ultimately benefiting the service provider.
The Psychology Behind Dark Patterns
Dark patterns aren’t just "bad design." They’re built on science, specifically the science of how our brains cut corners when making decisions. Instead of helping us, these tactics turn our natural habits into a profit engine for companies by steering us towards choices we didn't plan to make.
A Princeton study of 11,000 websites found dark patterns on 1 in 10. Some used as many as 15 different tricks to get users to click, buy, or share—proof this isn’t rare.
Here are a few of the brain quirks these dark patterns exploit:
- Default Bias: Most of us stick with whatever is pre-selected.
- Scarcity & FOMO: Fake timers or "limited stock" alerts create panic and push you to buy before you think.
- Social Proof: "1,203 people already bought this" nudges you to follow the crowd.
- Framing Effect: "5 for $20" feels like a better deal than "Buy 4 get 1 free," even though they’re identical.
This is what designers call nudging—shaping our environment to influence our decisions. Nudging can be helpful (like encouraging people to sign up for retirement plans), but dark patterns turn it into manipulation.
Picture a cookie consent box where the big, bright button screams "Accept All," while the privacy-friendly choice is hidden behind dull text and extra clicks. Technically we have a choice, but the deck is stacked.
In short, dark patterns prey on the mental shortcuts we all use every day. They’re designed to make the company’s preferred action feel like the easiest, safest, or smartest move—even when it’s not. Once you know the playbook, you can start spotting the traps before they catch you.
3 Ways to Outsmart Dark Patterns
So how do you protect yourself from being manipulated by dark patterns? Here are three strategies that put you back in control:
1. Slow Down Your Clicks
Dark patterns thrive on urgency. Before clicking "Next" or "Place Order," pause and do a quick audit. Expand every dropdown or section labeled recommended, optional, or included. Look for tiny checkmarks or toggles that might have been switched on without your consent. Finally, ask yourself: Did I actively choose this item, or was it chosen for me?
2. Hunt for the Hidden Exit
Whether it’s a cookie banner or a subscription cancellation, the least obvious button is usually the one that saves your privacy or your wallet. Take the extra minute to dig for “Decline,” “Opt Out,” or “Basic Plan.”
3. Use Privacy Tools
Browser extensions like uBlock Origin or Privacy Badger block many pop-ups and trackers that fuel manipulative design. Password managers can also prevent accidental one-click purchases by requiring you to re-enter credentials.
Final Thoughts
Dark patterns aren’t just annoying—they’re a billion-dollar strategy to separate you from your money and data. They work because they’re built on the very shortcuts our brains rely on to function in a fast-moving world. That’s why even smart, cautious people fall for them.
But awareness is power. Once you start recognizing the tactics—fake urgency, sneaky defaults, buried opt-outs—you can pause and choose on your terms. Companies design these traps to feel invisible, but when you see the strings, the spell breaks.
The next time a checkout timer starts ticking or a bright "Accept All" button tries to steal your attention, remember: you are the customer, not a target. Take the extra second to uncheck the box, click the smaller link, or walk away entirely.
Technology will keep evolving, and dark patterns will evolve with it. But your best defense will always be a sharper eye and a willingness to slow down. Spot the pattern, reclaim the choice, and you win the game they’re trying to play.
This piece is the 2nd in my Mind over Money series on consumer psychology. If you missed the first issue, read it using the link below:
- Loss Aversion
- Dark Pattern (current issue)
- Sunk Cost Fallacy (next issue)
- Paradox of Choice
- Fear, Uncertainty, Doubt
- Framing Effect
Don't forget to subscribe to get all future issues delivered straight to your inbox every Saturday.